- About us
- About colleges
-
Corporate services
- Corporate services
- Mental health and wellbeing
- Data Protection/GDPR
-
Employment Services - college workforce
- Employment Services - college workforce
- Employment: How we support members
- Introduction & Employment Helpline
- Absence & Sickness Management
- Contracts and T&Cs
- Disciplinary, Capability, Grievance & Harassment
- Equality, Diversity & Inclusion
- General Employee Relations & HR Issues
- Holiday/annual leave related
- Industrial Relations
- ONS reclassification related guidance
- Pay & Pensions
- Recruitment
- Redundancy, Restructuring & TUPE
- Safeguarding/Prevent
- Workforce Benchmarking, Surveys & Research
-
Governance
- Governance
- Governance: How we support members
- Governance Timeline
- Representation
- AoC National Chairs' Council
- National Governance Professionals' Group
- Code of Good Governance
- External Board Reviews
- Resources
- Governors Inductions
- Student Governor Inductions
- Student Governor Support Hub
- Guidance
- Hot Topics
- Governance Briefings
- Archive
-
Projects
- Projects
- Get Involved!
- Resources
- Contact the Projects Team
- Apprenticeship Workforce Development (AWD) Programme
- Creating a Greener London – Sustainable Construction Skills
- The 5Rs Approach to GCSE Maths Resits
- Creative Arts in FE 2024 – developing student voice through creativity
- DfE Multiply Capability Support Programme
- Digital Roles Across Non-digital Industries
- GCSE Resits Hub Project
- Pears Foundation Youth Social Action Programme: Phase 2
- T Level and T Level Foundation Year Provider Support Programme
- T Level Professional Development (TLPD) Offer
- The Valuing Enrichment Project
- Resources/Guidance
- Sustainability & Climate Action Hub
- Partnerships
- Honours Nomination
- Brexit
- Ofsted Inspection Support
- Recruitment and consultancy
-
Events and training
- Events and training
- Events
- AoC Annual Conference and Exhibition 2024
- T Level and T Level Foundation Year Events
- Events and training: How we support members
- Network Meetings
- Previous Events and Webinars
- In-House Training
- Senior Leadership Development Programme
- Early Career and Experienced Managers' Programme
- Sponsorship and Exhibition Opportunities
- Funding and finance
-
Policy
- Policy
- Meet the Policy Team
- Policy: How we support members
- Policy Areas
- Policy Briefings
- Submissions
- Policy Papers & Reports
- AoC Strategy Groups
-
AoC Reference Groups
- AoC Reference Groups
- 14-16 Reference Group
- 16-18 Reference Group
- Adults (inc. ESOL) Reference Group
- Apprenticeship Reference Group
- EDI Reference Group
- HE Reference Group
- HR Reference Group
- International Reference Group
- Mental Health Reference Group
- SEND Reference Group
- Sustainability & Climate Change Reference Group
- Technology Reference Group
- WorldSkills Reference Group
- Opportunity England
- Research unit
-
News, campaigns and parliament
- News, campaigns and parliament
- Post-election hub
- General and mayoral election resources
-
Comms advice and resources for colleges
- Comms advice and resources for colleges
- Media relations: 10 ways to build effective relationships with the media
- How to choose a PR agency
- Legal considerations for communications and media work
- How to plan for a new build
- Crisis communications: your go-to guide
- How to handle photo consent for media and marketing
- How to evaluate a PR and media campaign
- How to react to regulation, funding and restructuring issues
- How to react quickly and effectively to the media
- Working with the media: a complete guide
- How to write a compelling case study
- How to write for the web
- Communications, marketing and campaigns community
- AoC Newsroom
- AoC Blogs
- Work in Parliament
- AoC Campaigns
- Briefings
- Communications, media, marketing and research: How we support members
-
Equality, diversity and inclusion
- Equality, diversity and inclusion
- Equality, diversity and inclusion blogs
- AoC’s Equity, Diversity and Inclusion Charter
- AoC’s Equity, Diversity and Inclusion Charter for further education sector organisations
- AoC’s Equity, Diversity and Inclusion Charter signatories
- Diversity in Leadership
- Black FE Leadership Group and AoC partnership agreement
- AoC's Equity Exchange
- Equality, diversity and inclusion: how we support members
- Equality, diversity and inclusion case studies
- ETF Inclusive Leadership Coaching Programme
- Equality, diversity and inclusion briefings
- Home
- News, campaigns and parliament
- AoC Newsroom
- Leadership demand in FE
Leadership demand in FE
by Bernie Cullen, Recruitment Manager, Association of Colleges
In 2018, over 50 colleges appointed new Principals and CEOs, an unprecedented turnover of almost 20% across the sector. What does this mean for the supply of future college leaders?
The depleting talent pool
The pace of change in the FE sector has been remarkable in recent years, and this is reflected in the level of turnover in college leadership roles. In 2018, an unprecedented number of new Principals and CEOs took up post and, in the first three months of this year, over 20 colleges have appointed new leaders.
The potential candidate pool at this top level has been depleting rapidly, raising a question as to where the next tranche of leaders will come from. Many vacancies are coming about through retirements or individuals transitioning to other sectors and these are at a more rapid rate than aspiring leaders are developing and progressing, hence a net drain of top talent from the sector. This has several far-reaching implications for the sector as a whole.
Candidates are becoming more selective
Firstly, candidates have become more selective; whereas they have always reflected carefully on a college’s fit rather than apply for roles on a serial basis, there now appears to be an extra level of risk aversion and most will consider at length the likely repercussions of a college’s journey and strengths on their own future. The number of applications for Principal roles is likely to be smaller; whereas in the relative recruitment heyday of five years ago it wasn’t unusual to receive in excess of 30 applications, today’s selection panels are likely to have a choice of far fewer candidates and face competition from other processes at the same time.
Funding can affect advertised salaries
Secondly, a smaller candidate pool and increased competition create remuneration challenges, which give rise to fiscal and ethical dilemmas in the current climate. On the one hand, there may be a need to position salaries at the higher end of the pay scale to attract the best talent – this is a no-brainer for many commercial businesses. However, colleges’ appetites and abilities to do this are obviously limited by the current financial pressures in the sector, as well as the recently introduced Remuneration Code and ethical concerns about pay being reflective of – or at least sensitive to – opportunities within their local communities.
Risks and rewards of hiring outside the educational sector
So, what should colleges consider when planning to recruit a new CEO/Principal, given that demand may soon be outweighing supply? Firstly, whether it might be feasible to consider an appointment from outside FE and what the potential risks and rewards could be in this. Given the current challenges in the sector it would need to be weighed carefully in terms of a college’s size, structure and focus, strength of existing leadership team and governing body, and commitment to support and development. But with a potential sector leadership shortage from within FE, we need to be aware of the options, perhaps considering which backgrounds might have the best synergy to successfully transfer into FE and looking at a holistic way of supporting and developing individuals into the sector.
Successful planning and ongoing development
A sector-wide commitment to succession planning and development is critical, to ensure that we are continuously nurturing and preparing our next generation of leaders. There are some excellent development programmes available, through AoC, ETF and a number of other training partners. But it’s also key to constantly be stretching, developing and providing growth opportunities as part of people’s day to day roles, ensuring that they are exposed to cross-college remits and taking responsibility for key strategies. I will pick up more on this area in my next blog, as it’s such a key element of the sector’s success.
At AoC we are proactive in supporting governing bodies to make the most impactful appointments and our in-depth executive FE recruitment knowledge and access to AoC experts make us adept in sourcing and assessing the best talent. However, a whole sector approach to progression and development will be critical in ensuring that this talent is being replenished and that there is a supply of strong individuals to lead colleges to successful and sustainable futures.
For support with recruiting leaders at your college, check out the AoC’s executive recruitment service.