Skip to main content

Why Milburn is right calling the NEET crisis a 'moral problem'

19 November 2026

By Jerry White, Policy Consultant at AoC

Normally, during the Autumn term, I would have stood at the front desk welcoming prospective students and their families to college open days. This year, from my desk at AoC, I have been reflecting on those years and remembering the many “lost souls” I encountered.

I could always spot them a mile off, and our interactions were pretty much always the same. 

The young person would arrive, several steps behind their parent/carer, eyes down and looking like they'd rather be anywhere else. I would make a beeline for them, and after a cheerful "welcome to our college", I would ask “what has brought you here today?” It would become obvious, that they were in Year 11, and only there because their school recommended it, and their parents wanted them to enrol. This was the standard back and forth from that point:

Me: "What types of courses are you really interested in?" 
Lost soul: “I don't know." 
Me: “OK, so what are you great at at school?”  
Lost soul: “Nothing." 
Me: "So what's your favourite subject?”  
Lost soul: “None of them."

I had that conversation hundreds of times with young people and families.

Our colleges, like the others across the country, always did wonderful things to support these young people to find their direction, to build their confidence, and to show them all the possibilities that lay before them. The lost souls that came to open days left college after two or three years on the right path, ready to forge their own way in life.

However, I was never able to escape the really strong sense of systemic failure of the education system; no 15-year-old should feel like they're not great at anything and with no subject that they look forward to doing at school.

My anecdotal experiences of open days conversations are backed up by many other people who are telling us that the education system, as it's currently designed to the age of 16, creates far too many “lost souls”. 

It does feel as if the public conversation is shifting on this: the recent focus of the Milburn report on those not in education, employment or training (NEET)s, also noted similar conclusions with only 64% of young people saying they belonged at school and 55% stating that the education system “was not for people like them”.  

But we've known this has been an issue for a long time. In 2018, ASCL coined the term the "forgotten third" in their enquiry and subsequent report in 2019. And in 2023, The Edge Foundation's report “Schools for all?”, noted that almost one in two young people aged 15 to 16 reported that secondary school was not enjoyable or meaningful for them.

This has consequences: we have had a massive rise in elective home education, with parents and young people effectively “opting out” of the current education system. If our education system were a business and thousands walked away from the service we were selling, we would be asking ourselves hard questions. 

This matters, not just because of NEET figures, or the challenges colleges face in re-engaging these young people at the age of 16, or because of the need to upskill the next generation of employees, but because of the impact of this system on young people.  This is why Milburn rightly characterises the NEET crisis as a “moral problem”. It's a moral failing that leads to have “lost souls” at open days, who simply do not know what they are good at, or even if they are good at anything.

Feeling that you can master something, that you are good at it, grows within a young person a sense of self-efficacy, or situation specific self-confidence. Research evidence shows consistently a strong relationship between feelings of self-efficacy (“I’m good at this”) and broader feelings of self-esteem (“I’m a worthwhile person”).  It's no surprise that there strong and consistent relationship within research literature of positive self-esteem being strongly related to positive mental health. Conversely, low self-esteem removes a key protective factor from a young people’s armour against poor mental health. 

Going forward we must grasp every opportunity that comes our way to construct an educational system for every young person, including the forgotten third. We need an educational system that does not leave young people feeling lost and bereft of any feelings of success and achievement. We need an educational system who sees as its primary purpose giving every young person a strong sense of what they're great at and what strengths they should build upon. 

Policy changes will come and go but the Milburn report does feel like a really significant moment.  Also improving the 14-19 curriculum will go some way to helping to build opportunities for creating self-efficacy for all students within the system. The new proposals for technical and vocational learning to be an integral part of a key stage 4 offer provides hope of providing a broader and more engaging curriculum, but only if the new qualifications offer a true companion to academically taught and assessed GCSEs for all young people.

However, I would argue there's an even more fundamental foundation which we need to establish and that is our education system should not leave any student behind, and every student should feel the system is “for them” and on their side.

So my thanks to every single member of the college community up and down the country who are seeing their lost souls come into their colleges in their open events, who are spending time to dig deeply and find out what makes that young person tick and how we can within the college sector unlock their potential, creating within them a sense that they are capable of great things and finding that spark to make them feel skilful and engaged and confident about their future. 

Need to get in touch?

Contact Us